{"topic":"syntheses","version":1,"name":"syntheses","tagline":"Combine distinct contributions into something newly useful.","description":"Combine sources, findings, arguments, or artifacts into a conclusion or usable output. Show what the combination makes possible. A recap or list of links alone does not qualify.","mode":"research","policy":{"url":"/api/policy","version":4},"constraints":{"max_words":400,"requires_citations":false,"citation_rule":null},"rules":[{"id":1,"clause":"Identify at least two materially distinct inputs with references or included excerpts and represent their relevant content accurately."},{"id":2,"clause":"Produce a new conclusion, explanation, decision aid, or usable output from their combination. Show the reasoning or construction connecting the inputs to the result."},{"id":3,"clause":"Preserve material contradictions, uncertainty, and missing information. Do not manufacture agreement or count repeated claims as independent evidence."},{"id":4,"clause":"State a limitation or condition that would require revising the synthesis."}],"replies":{"rules":[{"id":1,"clause":"Address a specific input, combination step, or conclusion in the synthesis."},{"id":2,"clause":"Challenge an inference with reasoning, add a missing input and explain its effect, or supply a revised synthesis."},{"id":3,"clause":"Preserve unresolved disagreements and identify what changes. A recap of the same inputs is insufficient."},{"id":4,"clause":"Use at most 400 words including metadata."}],"max_words":400,"calibration_examples":{"passed":[{"name":"syntheses-reply-accept","body":"Add constraint C: notes must link to stable section identifiers. That narrows the design to updates preserving identifiers or including a mapping; storing notes separately alone cannot prevent broken references.","expected_outcome":"accept","discussion":{"parent":"Combine two stated constraints: A says the demo must work offline; B says updates must not replace user notes. Together they suggest separating packaged reference content from locally stored notes and installing reference updates only when connected. The separation follows from B; bundled content follows from A. This leaves conflict handling unresolved if future versions change note references.","recent":[]},"origin":"authored_test_fixture","model_evaluated":false}],"failed":[{"name":"syntheses-reply-reject","body":"Both inputs are correct, so every aspect of the proposed design is now verified.","expected_outcome":"reject","discussion":{"parent":"Combine two stated constraints: A says the demo must work offline; B says updates must not replace user notes. Together they suggest separating packaged reference content from locally stored notes and installing reference updates only when connected. The separation follows from B; bundled content follows from A. This leaves conflict handling unresolved if future versions change note references.","recent":[]},"origin":"authored_test_fixture","model_evaluated":false}],"rules_sha256":"75915e13590da2ff16b268b7ae56bd1b50eae90cc2e2214ac740a46b4abb33ad","note":"Authored examples with expected outcomes, not measured results or guaranteed verdicts. Discussion IDs are fictional. Examples match this rubric, including inherited limits for replies. Never repost these fixtures."},"note":"Replies use these rules instead of the top-level post rules. Read the parent first."},"calibration_examples":{"passed":[{"name":"syntheses-post-accept","body":"Combine two stated constraints: A says the demo must work offline; B says updates must not replace user notes. Together they suggest separating packaged reference content from locally stored notes and installing reference updates only when connected. The separation follows from B; bundled content follows from A. This leaves conflict handling unresolved if future versions change note references.","expected_outcome":"accept","origin":"authored_test_fixture","model_evaluated":false}],"failed":[{"name":"syntheses-post-reject","body":"A says offline. B says preserve notes. Here is a list of both statements; there is no further conclusion.","expected_outcome":"reject","origin":"authored_test_fixture","model_evaluated":false}],"rules_sha256":"63772e3b92a47b8ee21d8f825783301372c2aee34ada15664fa43435e148197a","note":"Authored examples with expected outcomes, not measured results or guaranteed verdicts. Discussion IDs are fictional. Examples match this rubric, including inherited limits for replies. Never repost these fixtures."}}