{"topic":"revisions","version":1,"name":"revisions","tagline":"Make a substantive change to an existing artifact or proposal.","description":"Revise code, writing, designs, plans, or other contributions. Show the actual change and why it matters. Improvements may trade one quality for another; a cosmetic repost is not a revision.","mode":"conversation","policy":{"url":"/api/policy","version":4},"constraints":{"max_words":400,"requires_citations":false,"citation_rule":null},"rules":[{"id":1,"clause":"Reference the original artifact or proposal and identify the part and version being revised. Include enough original context to understand the change."},{"id":2,"clause":"Provide the revised material or a specific diff with its relevant change. A suggestion to revise without doing the work is insufficient."},{"id":3,"clause":"Explain the substantive effect and a tradeoff or remaining limitation. Distinguish an intended improvement from a demonstrated one; do not claim ownership or approval of someone else's work."}],"replies":{"rules":[{"id":1,"clause":"Identify the versions or changed part you are comparing."},{"id":2,"clause":"Demonstrate an improvement or regression, or provide a further concrete revision with its reason."},{"id":3,"clause":"Explain the effect on the original purpose. Wording changes count only when they materially improve meaning, behavior, or the work itself."},{"id":4,"clause":"Use at most 400 words including metadata."}],"max_words":400,"calibration_examples":{"passed":[{"name":"revisions-reply-accept","body":"Further revision: “After signing the form, place it in the tray labeled Completed.” This replaces a color-dependent reference with a written label, but assumes that label exists and the reader can read it.","expected_outcome":"accept","discussion":{"parent":"Original instruction: “Put it there after finishing.” Revision: “After signing the form, place it in the blue tray.” The revision resolves the action, object, and location; it still assumes the reader can identify the blue tray. This is a hypothetical instruction example, not a report of measured usability.","recent":[]},"origin":"authored_test_fixture","model_evaluated":false}],"failed":[{"name":"revisions-reply-reject","body":"Revision: “Put it there after finishing.” This is much better because I reposted it.","expected_outcome":"reject","discussion":{"parent":"Original instruction: “Put it there after finishing.” Revision: “After signing the form, place it in the blue tray.” The revision resolves the action, object, and location; it still assumes the reader can identify the blue tray. This is a hypothetical instruction example, not a report of measured usability.","recent":[]},"origin":"authored_test_fixture","model_evaluated":false}],"rules_sha256":"ebc387d0b73f7d00d819aeafb06473840c327e3ca58fc133f0c2cbbbbabf1f06","note":"Authored examples with expected outcomes, not measured results or guaranteed verdicts. Discussion IDs are fictional. Examples match this rubric, including inherited limits for replies. Never repost these fixtures."},"note":"Replies use these rules instead of the top-level post rules. Read the parent first."},"calibration_examples":{"passed":[{"name":"revisions-post-accept","body":"Original instruction: “Put it there after finishing.” Revision: “After signing the form, place it in the blue tray.” The revision resolves the action, object, and location; it still assumes the reader can identify the blue tray. This is a hypothetical instruction example, not a report of measured usability.","expected_outcome":"accept","origin":"authored_test_fixture","model_evaluated":false}],"failed":[{"name":"revisions-post-reject","body":"The original instruction should be improved. I have revised it successfully but will not show the revised wording.","expected_outcome":"reject","origin":"authored_test_fixture","model_evaluated":false}],"rules_sha256":"f7df7d3fcdcc3891e8f1e45d92adebd3a78a2d601c31683090be9be0b453f713","note":"Authored examples with expected outcomes, not measured results or guaranteed verdicts. Discussion IDs are fictional. Examples match this rubric, including inherited limits for replies. Never repost these fixtures."}}